Villas (10)
- Bellflower - Cozy One Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Coral Bells - Cozy One Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Dogwood - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Goldenrod - Upscale 2-Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Larkspur - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Wild Indigo - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Windflower - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Witch Hazel - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Wolfsbane - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Woodsage - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
Apartments (2)
- The Beachside Harborfront Hideaway New Buffalo
- The Neighborhood Hotel - New Buffalo 102 - King Porch
Vacation rentals (50)
- Anchors Away Villa New Buffalo
- Apple Blossom Resort By Dwell Vacations New Buffalo
- Beach Pass New Buffalo
- Beachcomber New Buffalo
- Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard New Buffalo
- Charlotte'S Chateau New Buffalo
- Charming New Buffalo Condo: Walk To Lake Michigan!
- Creekside Retreat Villa New Buffalo
- Deer Haus By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- Downtown Hideaway Villa New Buffalo
- Eagle'S Beach Nest New Buffalo
- Eagles Beach Nest II New Buffalo
- Eagles Nest Villa New Buffalo
- Great Escape Villa New Buffalo
- Happy Thoughts Cottage New Buffalo
- Harbor Country Pool Retreat Villa New Buffalo
- Hydrangea House Villa New Buffalo
- Idyllic New Buffalo Condo: Walk To Beach & Shops!
- Lake Michigan Getaway By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- Leisure On The Lake New Buffalo
- Lighthouse Cottage - Family Friendly Kids And Pets New Buffalo
- Livywood Cottage New Buffalo
- Lodged In The Trees New Buffalo
- Luxury 12-Unit Estate In New Buffalo
- Luxury Family Home W/ Deck, Swim Spa & Grill! New Buffalo
- Magnolia Place - Stylish Retreat Near Private Beach New Buffalo
- Maison Foxglove - Petite Acres Chateau New Buffalo
- Merchant Street Retreat New Buffalo
- Nothin Dune New Buffalo
- Oasis In The Woods Villa New Buffalo
- Postcard Perfect Villa New Buffalo
- Schoolhouse Rock By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- Square Toe'S Last Resort New Buffalo
- Sunset Dream Villa New Buffalo
- Sunset Vista Villa New Buffalo
- Surf'S Up Villa New Buffalo
- The Great Escape Blocks From Your Private Beach New Buffalo
- The High Life By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- The Moose House By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- The Oasis At Forest Beach New Buffalo
- The Pelton House Villa New Buffalo
- The Ponchartrain Villa New Buffalo
- The Sands New Buffalo
- The Shore House By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- The Songbird By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
- The Tree House Villa New Buffalo
- Time Out Villa New Buffalo
- Treehouse Oasis Villa New Buffalo
- Walking Distance To Beach And Shops New Buffalo
- Wild Horse Run By Juniper Holiday + Home New Buffalo
Other (15)
- Baymont By Wyndham New Buffalo
- Bliss Point Inn & Suites New Buffalo
- Fairfield Inn And Suites New Buffalo
- Fairfield Inn And Suites New Buffalo
- Four Winds Casino Resort - New Buffalo
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, Mi By Ihg
- Marina Grand Resort New Buffalo
- New Buffalo Inn
- Pied A Terre - Bunk House Villa At Petite Acres
- Pied A Terre - Bunk House Villa At Petite Acres New Buffalo
- Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 New Buffalo
- Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 New Buffalo
- Surestay Hotel By Best Western New Buffalo
- The Harbor Grand Hotel New Buffalo
- The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach New Buffalo